
Planets in Composite
Robert Hand

Two birth charts combined into one, read as the chart of your relationship itself.
What a Composite Chart Reads
In the introduction to Planets in Composite: Analyzing Human Relationships (1975), Robert Hand points to something we have all seen: two people who by any outside measure make no sense together, yet get along well and are both content. His explanation is that when two people come together, being together calls up parts of each of them that hadn't shown before, and those new parts belong to neither person. They belong to the relationship. So two people together are really three things: each of them, and the relationship between them.
If the relationship is a thing in its own right, it ought to have its own chart. The composite chart is that chart. You take the midpoint of each pair of matching planets: the midpoint of the two Suns is the composite Sun, the midpoint of the two Moons is the composite Moon, and so on through Mercury, Venus and the rest, until you have a third chart. Hand calls it the most reliable and descriptive new technique he has ever come across. The book first explains how to cast and read the chart, then works through five case studies. The last twelve chapters are delineations, starting with the houses and then giving one chapter to each planet: 374 interpretations of the Sun, Moon and planets in each house and in aspect to one another, plus 41 on the Moon's nodes.
When many planets gather in one house of the composite, the relationship turns around that house's affairs. The fourth house, for instance, is about a shared past and roots, so a couple with planets clustered there tends to buy property and make a home together.
Each partner has a temper of their own, but some ways of being together, such as leaving things unsaid until the pressure can't be held and then blowing up, exist only when the two are together. That is the third thing Hand means.
The Book's Contents
- Introduction
- Casting the Chart
- Reading the Chart
- Case Studies
- Houses
- Sun
- Moon
- Mercury
Where the Chart Comes From
Hand did not invent the composite chart. John Townley, who wrote the foreword, says its origins are unclear. The German astrologer Edith Wangemann reported that two researchers in Germany were already working with it in the 1920s, but the technique is older than that, and like a good folk song it has to be considered traditional. Most astrologers in Britain and America first heard of it in 1974, when Samuel Weiser published Townley's The Composite Chart. Townley also makes one point clear in the foreword: a composite chart is at bottom a midpoint chart. In the late 1960s few Americans understood midpoints, and a few years later every student had to learn them. Midpoints had their standard text in Reinhold Ebertin's book, and Townley considers Hand's book the standard text for composite charts.
Hand traces the midpoint line himself in Chapter 1. A midpoint combines the natures of two planets. The Uranian school and cosmobiology are both built around midpoints, and Dane Rudhyar and Charles Jayne use them too, so a composite chart made of midpoints stays within the tradition.

The book goes into the calculation in detail. The houses do not take the midpoint of the two Ascendants as the first-house cusp. Hand calculates only the composite Midheaven, then erects a fresh set of houses for the latitude of the place where the two people now live, or where the relationship is happening. The midpoint of the two Ascendants is called the composite Ascendant and stays on the chart as a sensitive point. The part he reworked himself was the composite for more than two people. He first learned an older method, and one day it gave a very strong twelfth house in the chart of himself and two old friends, meaning the three of them couldn't get along. He checked and found that the older method had calculated the Midheaven wrongly. From then on he worked out the principles the book uses on his own: the zodiac is a circle, and it can't be treated as a straight line running from 0° Aries.
Synastry sets two charts side by side and looks at the aspects the planets in one make to the planets in the other. Hand says this kind of reading is full of ambiguity and the composite has almost none, because good relationships and difficult ones both show plainly, and the chart can point to where the difficulty lies. Two people whose synastry contacts are mostly very negative may still look, in their composite, like a couple at ease together. Hand doesn't throw out the old method because of this, though. He still uses traditional synastry, he just doesn't rely on it alone.
Hand himself wasn't convinced at first. When he first came across composite charts in 1972 he wasn't impressed and took them for a mathematical device. Later he admitted this was a prejudice with no experience behind it. The book began as an effort to write better text for Para Research's computerized relationship reports, and the house and aspect delineations in the book were used in those reports as well. Townley says in the foreword that Hand brings humor to the subject, along with “the critical eye of a mathematician and statistical researcher.”
Hand on Difficult Relationships
When he explains the first step in reading a chart, Hand says relationships are strange things. The real reason two people are together is often not what others assume. The wish for love and happiness can be overridden by the wish for security, money or status, and some relationships exist only because each person happens to meet a need in the other that has nothing to do with love or happiness. He goes on to say that every relationship fills some need at the time and in the circumstances in which it happens, even if to others it looks twisted or harmful. Sometimes a person even needs a painful relationship, and will pass up a truly good one because it doesn't fit the need of the moment.
So when he reads a composite chart, he doesn't start by judging whether the relationship is good. The first thing he does is go back to the two birth charts and see what each person wants from a relationship and what kind of person each is drawn to. A relationship that looks wrong to outsiders can usually be explained once you read it in that order.
His reading of Saturn in the seventh house works the same way. Saturn is the planet of separation and restraint, and in the house of marriage it looks fatal to a marriage. Hand says it isn't. Saturn binds two people through real responsibilities and obligations, and sometimes they couldn't separate even if they wanted to. As for the worst case, this is how he reasons:
If you have settled that you want to have a relationship, you have already proved that Saturn is not operating at the malefic level
He doesn't read a parting as a failure either. A relationship can end painfully, and afterward each person may be where they belong.
Hand on Talking Things Through
In the third-house chapter and again under Mercury, Hand comes back to one idea: two people truly in love should understand each other without having to speak. He says the hurt is worst when they find that this unspoken understanding isn't there, and if you keep acting on guesses, in the end
you are dealing with your partner as if he or she were a creation of your own mind
Hand says Mercury is about whether two people can speak each other's language.
In the fifth house he meets a different situation. Many relationships last because both people are performing for each other, each trying to be what the other wants, and when the truth comes out the relationship falls apart. Hand says an ideal relationship lets both people be themselves with each other, without effort.
With composite Venus in the seventh house, the greatest danger is giving in too much: holding back grievances to keep the peace until they pile up and all come out at once. His advice is short: say it, because a good relationship won't be upset by it. With composite Mars in the twelfth, he suggests the two of you write down what you expect of each other as an agreement, and in writing it you will find many demands you weren't even aware of. This isn't only for lovers. The delineations often treat love and marriage separately from friendship and business partnership, so friends, partners and colleagues can each find their own part.

Chapter by Chapter
The book has fifteen chapters. The first three are on method, Chapter 4 is on the houses, Chapters 5 through 14 take one planet each, and Chapter 15 is on the Moon's nodes. From Chapter 5 on, every chapter follows the same pattern: a general section on what the planet means in a composite chart, then the planet in each of the twelve houses, one entry per house, then its conjunction, sextile, square, trine and opposition with each planet after it and with the composite Ascendant. Throughout, Hand addresses the couple as “the two of you.”
Introduction and Chapter 1: Casting the Chart
The introduction sets out Hand's own explanation. Each planet is like a directed pull in the heavens, and a planet's position in the composite chart is the result of combining the two people's pulls. He makes a point of saying that “pull” is a figure of speech, not gravity. Chapter 1 teaches how to cast the chart, and the difficulty is in the details. Any two points on a circle have two midpoints, 180° apart. Normally you take the one on the shorter arc, but when two planets are more than 150° apart, the two midpoints are about equally strong and both have to be considered. This rule produces combinations that can't occur in a birth chart, such as the Sun opposite Mercury, and Hand says to read that as a conjunction. At the end of the chapter he notes that transits and progressions can be applied to a composite chart too. He doesn't much trust solar and lunar return charts, so he leaves them out of the case studies.
Chapter 2: Reading the Chart
The book doesn't deal with signs. It gives no composite rising sign and no planets in signs, and it doesn't use signs to assign house rulers. Hand says that at the time he had not settled whether signs work in a composite chart, and he would rather leave it for readers to test from experience. The chapter also lays out nine steps for reading: first the two birth charts, then whether any house holds four or more planets, then in turn the houses and aspects of the composite Sun and Moon, Venus and Mars, planets close to the four angles, the first, fifth, seventh and eleventh houses, Saturn, and finally whatever is left. He suggests beginners follow this order and drop it once they are comfortable. Astrology, he says, is an art that requires tremendous flexibility, so don't become a slave to this or any other routine.
Chapter 3: Case Studies
Chapter 3 has five case studies. One couple is taken through all nine steps, one is there for the comparison with synastry, and the last three are well-known figures. The final pair shows that the composite chart isn't only for love affairs. It can read even the subtlest relationship.
Chapter 4: Houses
The houses mean broadly what they mean in a birth chart, but they have to be thought through for two people. The tenth house, for example, is career in a birth chart, and in a composite it is the relationship's standing and the purpose it exists for. More important, the far midpoint also has an effect, so when you read a planet in a house it is best to read the opposite house along with it. Hand says a composite chart almost works as six pairs of houses, and the twelve don't stand on their own. In the twelfth-house entry he advises against marriage for two people with a very strong twelfth house, but he also says some people's unconscious habits fit a partner's so exactly that they can't leave each other however hard it gets, and a relationship like that can't simply be written off.
Chapter 5: Sun
The houses of the Sun and Moon say why the relationship exists and what it revolves around, and the Sun's aspects are the most important energy pattern in the chart. When the Sun is blocked, keeping the relationship going takes effort. When it is well placed, the relationship is a natural expression of the two people. Composite Sun in the first house, for example, makes the two of you a unit, stronger facing the world together than either of you alone, but you need to watch that you don't care so much about how others see you that you overlook problems they can't see. The entry on squares and oppositions between the Sun and Saturn contains this sentence: the only valid reason for a relationship is to make your lives more complete together than they are individually.
Chapter 6: Moon
The Sun says what a relationship does. The Moon says whether the two people are close at heart. With a good Moon, however different your backgrounds, you feel you understand each other better than other couples do. With a poor Moon, a sense of distance creeps in easily. With composite Moon in the twelfth house, the two of you hide your feelings, so well that you don't know them yourselves, and the greatest danger is emotional dishonesty, because feelings held down will sooner or later break out destructively. In the entry on the Moon conjunct Neptune, Hand urges the two not to ask too much of the relationship. You are both only human and have to accept human frailty.
Chapter 7: Mercury
Hand says Mercury's most negative trait is shallowness, though it isn't a serious fault. With composite Mercury conjunct the composite Ascendant, the two of you talk a lot and spark ideas in each other, and you would work well together in communications or business. But though you go through a great deal together, you often only skim the surface, and he simply reminds you not to let the shallow crowd out the deeper emotional experiences.
Chapter 8: Venus
Venus rules love and the capacity to form relationships. Its deepest meaning is that two people are drawn together naturally by what is in each of them, with no outside force, and that assumes each of them has already become fully themselves:
In human terms, this means that you have to be yourself in order to love someone else.
A person who lives by other people's expectations, without regard to what they want inside, isn't yet complete enough to love someone else. Hand also says a relationship doesn't need a good Venus to survive, but a good Venus makes it worth having. The entry on Venus conjunct Saturn says the feeling is real, only cool and restrained, often with a sense of the wrong time and the wrong place. A relationship like this is stable and lasting, and anyone looking for thrilling romance won't find it here.
Chapter 9: Mars
Hand doesn't advise holding conflict down. He says some conflict in a relationship, perhaps a lot, can't be avoided, and conflict itself shouldn't be suppressed. What matters is that the two people's ego drives are basically compatible, because conflict mostly starts when one person touches the weakest point in the other's sense of self. With composite Mars square or opposite composite Saturn, anger simmers underneath and erupts now and then, and he advises letting it out more often and more gently, instead of through barbed remarks.
Chapter 10: Jupiter
Two people with composite Jupiter in the first house won't feel much bitterness even if they part. Whatever happens later, both know they gained a great deal from being together, and that the relationship made each of them a better, fuller person.
Chapter 11: Saturn
Hand says Saturn signifies fear, and fear generates negative energy that draws in the very thing you dread, so in the area where Saturn falls the two of you have to learn to relax, all the more since its limits often look larger than they are. With composite Saturn in the first house, the relationship is very self-contained. Outsiders can't see the feeling between you, since neither the good nor the bad shows. At worst it is as if a wall stood between you, and Hand's remedy is to take the barriers down as far as you can and talk about everything.
Chapters 12 to 14: Uranus, Neptune, Pluto
Uranus marks the part of the relationship you have to let go of, letting it go its own way, because if you force it to follow rules it heads the opposite way. Neptune rules disappointment, illusion and the slow dissolving of things, and it also rules ideals, and the two are linked. Hand says that to a considerable extent all true love rests on idealizing some side of the other person, but you have to remember reality and not turn your partner into someone they aren't. Pluto is the force that puts a relationship through drastic change, as old ways leave and a new order arrives. The way to meet it is to let go, since clinging to what should end won't save it. Where two people can't separate even though they don't want to be together, he makes a point of saying that the relationship was created by the two of you, with the needs each of you admits and the needs you don't.
Chapter 15: Moon's Nodes
Here Hand drops the old idea that the North Node is good and the South Node bad. He follows the reading of Alfred Witte in Germany, treating the nodes as one axis that rules unions, associations, groups and connections between people, so it bears on every kind of relationship. His own view is that the difference between north and south shows only when a planet is conjunct one of the nodes, with the North Node leaning toward coming together and the South toward coming apart. Aspects to the nodes are weaker than aspects between planets and only add detail to an outline already drawn. On the nodes in the houses, he says he can't yet speak clearly, so this edition leaves them out.
How to Read This Book
Start with the nine steps in Chapter 2, then read the first case in Chapter 3 to watch Hand work through one chart step by step, then go back to Chapter 1 for how to cast the chart. The four hundred or so delineations that follow are for looking things up, not for reading straight through. With a composite chart in hand, look up the houses and aspects of the Sun and Moon first, then Venus, Mars and Saturn. A single delineation read on its own can easily frighten you. Hand says in several places that no single configuration makes or breaks a relationship, and you have to look at the whole chart.
After the first few cases Hand came to a new view: a planet in the composite refers to whichever of the two people is more like that planet, with the Sun and Mars more often the man and the Moon and Venus more often the woman, and he adds his own condition, if they are playing traditional roles. Read today, this is only a hint you can check for yourselves. Aspects among Saturn, Uranus, Neptune and Pluto are much the same for everyone born within a few years of each other, so he mostly treats them as something a generation shares, reading them on their own only when one of the pair is conjunct an angle. On the signs of the composite, the sensitive point called the Vertex, and the nodes in the houses, he says plainly that he isn't yet sure, and he gives no delineations. He also reminds the reader again and again that these delineations are examples, not final verdicts, and writes:
The student is asked to use this book as a guide, not as a crutch.
Everyone has to read charts from their own experience, without putting his experience, or anyone else's, in its place.
The Essence of Your Relationship in Depth reads your own composite chart by Hand's method. When you order, you give the date, exact time and place of birth for both of you, along with the city where the two of you live now, because Hand erects the houses for where the couple lives. You also choose what you are to each other: romantic partners, spouses, friends, business partners or colleagues. Where the book writes separately about love, friendship and partnership, the report uses only what fits your kind of relationship. Each planet in the composite is the midpoint of the two people's matching planets, calculated precisely, and the houses are built from the composite Midheaven for the latitude of your city, so the chart may differ from the composite charts you usually find online.
The report follows the book's nine steps. It goes back to each of your birth charts first, to see what each of you wants in a relationship like this. Then it looks for a house of the composite that holds four or more planets, whose affairs would be the main affairs of the relationship, and if there is none it turns to the houses of the composite Sun and Moon. After that it reads where the composite Sun and Moon fall and the aspects they make, how Venus and Mars let the two of you complement each other, and how the planets near the four angles and the composite Ascendant connect the relationship to the world outside. It also covers the first, fifth, seventh and eleventh houses, the four houses of relationship, the strengths and weaknesses Saturn shows, and the houses of Mercury, Jupiter and the three outer planets. The Moon's nodes are read only when a planet or the Ascendant in your composite makes an aspect to them, and planets that need both midpoints only when your chart has one. Finally it puts what came before together and closes on Hand's attitude to reading a chart. It doesn't read the signs of the composite chart, and it doesn't compare your two charts aspect by aspect as synastry does.
The Essence of Your Relationship in DepthSee report · $29From the chart to a written reading
The reports below are written readings, sent as a PDF by email.