
Barriers and Boundaries
Liz Greene

Greene on the defences in a chart, and on what they protect.
What a Defence Protects
Liz Greene opens this book by taking apart something we often hear. When we tell someone close to us that they are being defensive, what we often mean is “you didn't give me what I wanted,” and when a therapist says it to a client, it often means “you won't accept my interpretation of you.” She asks everyone to stop using “defence” as an insult for a while, and to work out what it is before going any further.
Barriers and Boundaries: The Horoscope and the Defences of the Personality belongs to the CPA Seminar Series from the Centre for Psychological Astrology Press in London, and was first published in 1996. It is the record of two days of seminars, both given at Regents College in London. The first, on 30 October 1994, covers the kinds of defence described by psychoanalysis, goes through the four elements and the twelve signs, and then shows how planets and aspects work as defences. The second, on 13 November of the same year, is given entirely to Saturn and Chiron. While Greene talks, people in the room cut in and ask questions.
The whole book rests on one idea. A defence is how a living thing keeps itself intact, and what a person defends is exactly what they most need and value, the thing they could not survive losing. In Greene's words:
We do not defend what we do not care about.
Turn that around, and once you see what someone fears and what they are holding off, you know what matters most to them. She doesn't list defences as faults. Only when a defence grows so large that it cuts away parts of the personality that matter just as much, and the person can meet reality only through it, does she say that they have stopped protecting themselves and started to destroy themselves.
Greene also talks about how watery and airy people find each other hard to bear. To the more watery one, the other seems cold, unfeeling and selfish, almost abnormal. For the airy one, though, those defences are exactly what it takes to keep their privacy and emotional balance and not be swamped by other people's demands. An astrologer or counselor who leans toward water can easily take the watery side and decide the airy person needs treatment. Greene says you could just as well turn it around: the watery need is itself a defence against the fear of being alone. What feels like a matter of survival to one person may not to another, and no one, however much astrology or psychology they know, has the right to decide for someone else whose defences are normal.
The Book's Contents
- Part One: The Psychology of Defences and Their Astrological Significators
- Introduction
- Psychoanalytic interpretations of defences
- Defence mechanisms in the zodiac signs
- Planets and planetary aspects as defence systems
- Defences and projection
- More example charts and group discussion
- Part Two: Saturn and Chiron as Defence Mechanisms
- An overview of Saturn and Chiron
- Saturn
Where She Parts Ways with Freud
The idea of defences comes from psychoanalysis. At the start Greene mentions Anna Freud's The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defence, and the great deal of work Freud did on the defences that grow out of each stage of childhood. Because of this, people tend to talk about defences in the language of pathology and to see them in an adult as unwanted and harmful, which she calls an unfortunate connotation. She also says plainly that astrology students usually prefer Jung, whose inclusive, symbolic approach sits closer to the astrological view of the world. But Jung spent little time on defences, and Freud looked far more closely at how a person suffers in everyday life. She asks anyone in the room with a prejudice against Freud to set it aside for now.
Freud divided defences into three kinds, matching three periods of childhood: oral, anal and Oedipal. Greene goes her own way in two places. The first is where defences come from. Freud traced an adult's oral defences to a wound in the first year of life. Greene says nearly everyone met something painful as a small child, yet the same event can feel like the end of the world to one child and pass with a shrug for another, so what matters is a person's inborn temperament, and certain chart placements describe exactly that temperament. The second is how many kinds there are. She adds a fourth basic defence that Freud hinted at but never developed: dissociation, like unplugging the psychological telephone. That gives four defences for the four elements. Water defends through fusion, earth through control, fire through competition, and air through dissociation. For anyone who finds the word “anal” jarring, she says “control” will do.

Much of what astrology books say then needs a second reading. Greene says many of the “character traits” that textbooks give the signs are really that sign's defences. Telling a Taurus not to be so stubborn, or a Virgo not to be so critical, does no good at all, because that is how each one protects itself with the strengths of its own nature. Her own roots are in psychoanalysis. When she talks about how people blame their parents or themselves, she borrows Melanie Klein's idea of “splitting.” On Saturn she cites Rudhyar's view that Saturn, more than the Sun, is a person's individuality, because the Sun is like a gift from the gods and Saturn has to be earned. On Chiron, she says some of the books written about it at the time were badly naive, all about its helping side, with the word “wounded” in small print, and very different from what she saw in charts and transits.
Saturn and Being Refused
On the Saturn day, Greene repeats things she often hears from clients. People with Saturn in Gemini say “My parents never talked to me,” “All they talked about at dinner was the weather,” “No one listened to me.” Close behind there is often a harder sentence: “Maybe they found me boring,” or “Maybe I just wasn't intelligent enough.” It is this second sentence that Greene picks up. Saturn makes a person feel denied, and feel it as punishment, as if wanting the thing were wrong in itself. So by the end of the story the person is blaming the parents and also themselves.
She grants that there are some truly terrible parents, and says that fortunately they are in the minority. Most are ordinary people doing their best who simply can't meet one part of the child's temperament. And from very early on a child helps to bring about its own rejection, reaching out already wearing an air of “you could never give me this.” She then asks for an honest question: was this really never given to me, or does it matter so much to me that no amount would ever be enough?
Where Saturn is concerned, no family can get it right.
Greene also says that playing down your own loneliness and sense of betrayal as just the ordinary experience everybody goes through is a Saturn defence too. Loneliness and betrayal have filled myth, poetry and drama for centuries because they matter so much, and what a person feels is their own, since no one else has lived it in exactly the same way.
Questions to Ask Yourself
The next time you and your partner argue about whether to go out, it is worth asking whether what you are guarding is a kind of security where everything stays where it is and nothing goes anywhere without your consent. When the other person presses harder and you grow colder, you might remember what she says about Capricorn, whose message is “I will express love when I choose to, not when you want me to.” That isn't coldness of heart. It is a need for boundaries and for keeping hold of oneself.
If a job makes you unhappy and you still can't leave, or one situation has kept you stuck for years, Greene suggests asking: “What does this cage help me avoid?” She says Saturn's greatest fear may be freedom, because freedom means relying on yourself and perhaps showing where you fall short. Another moment is harder to recognize. Your partner most needs a word of praise, and what comes out of your mouth is “Couldn't the publisher have chosen a better cover?”, and when that is pointed out, “You're too sensitive.” Greene calls this Saturnian envy. Envy in itself is not a flaw, she says, and once you recognize it, you can see clearly what you really want.
A longer-term question comes around thirty. By then Saturn has gone once around the chart, and the defences built early in life have set. Greene says it is sometimes as if a voice reminds you that the walls are well built but the doors and windows are blocked, so how do you plan to get out? Ignore that voice, and around forty, when transiting Saturn reaches the point opposite natal Saturn, the bill arrives with interest.

Chapter by Chapter
The book has no chapters. Each day's seminar makes up one part, and the original divides the text only with subheadings. Below, in order, neighboring subheadings are taken together.
Introduction and the Psychoanalytic Defences
The introduction places defences within life as a whole. Reproduction, law, science and art, religion, even astrology itself all contain an element of defence, and she asks astrology students why they study it. Then come Freud's three kinds of defence, and the oral one is the easiest to grasp. Some people panic when their partner merely goes around the corner to buy a loaf of bread, and explode when the partner comes home from work half an hour late. Greene says this is hunger, not love, and the “breast” need not be a person, since a workplace or a huge institution can serve. On the control defence, she asks who in the room finds it hard to say “no” to people, and at least a third raise their hands. Many people, she says, have too little of this defence. Her measure is that everyone has all three, and having too little or too much of any one of them brings a great deal of suffering.
Defence Mechanisms in the Signs
This part goes through the signs element by element, and one of its ideas is that what a sign most needs is often what its opposite sign most fears. Scorpio fears stagnation, which feels to it like the end of life itself, so it will poke at a settled situation, and what Taurus fears is exactly the change Scorpio wants. The four elements also come to know the world in different ways. She describes two gardeners: the Aquarian gardener buys thirty books on herbaceous perennials, and the Virgo gardener takes a cutting from a neighbor and sees whether it survives the winter. These inborn defences, she says, are as much a given as the color of our eyes, and anyone who insists that a person give one up has to answer a question: what are you going to put in its place?
When we talk about defences, we are invariably talking about fear.
Planets and Aspects as Defence Systems
Here Greene gives an example. Someone has been rejected in a close relationship, and every planet in the chart has something to say. The Moon says, “Without you, what will I do in this empty house?” Neptune says, “I was never good enough for you anyway.” Saturn mutters that it should never have got in so deep in the first place. Uranus goes to the ephemeris and decides it must be a bad Saturn transit. Jupiter asks, “What am I supposed to learn from this?” Mercury says, “Let's talk it through.” Mars has the hardest time, because being rejected means losing power, so it would rather blow up than say “You really hurt me.” Which voices are usually loudest depends on what a person identifies with, and the ones that get drowned out come back later by a roundabout route.
She also asks us to picture the planets in a chart as a group of people living together, and to see who gets on with whom and who is left out. A planet in an uncongenial sign, she says, is like someone wearing another person's costume. Mars in Libra, for instance, is a burly Homeric warrior who has to wear a beige silk suit to dinner with the Queen Mother, terrified of using the wrong fork, and who calls around all his friends one by one before he makes any decision.
Defences and Projection
On projection, Greene first separates two things. Projection is not in itself a defence. It is a natural process, in which something in us that we haven't yet recognized lands on someone else. Once it mixes with a strong defence, though, we can't help defending ourselves against the person carrying the projection. She says the enemy is always real, and what we need to sort out is whether it is inside, outside, or both. Defences also have an awkward tendency to draw in the very thing they guard against, and the more often this repeats, the more firmly it holds.
An Overview of Saturn and Chiron
At the start of the second day Greene explains why these two planets get a day of their own. Every sign and every planet has its own way of defending, but Saturn and Chiron also point to the places where life has hurt us. Their defences carry suspicion and self-doubt. They are long-standing fortifications, always manned, like suits of armor. She asks everyone to keep one word in mind, “humiliation,” which she says will come up all day. It is harder to bear than plain rejection, because it carries shame, the feeling of being flawed inside from birth. She also says that over the years, nearly every important relationship she and her clients have looked at showed a close synastry aspect between one person's Saturn or Chiron and the other's personal planets. It seems we need someone else to touch these two planets before we become aware of them.
Saturn's Defences
Greene lays out Saturn's ways of protecting its sore spot one at a time: fake compensation, avoidance, projection, scapegoating, contempt, pride and envy, and finally withdrawal and self-pity. The easiest to spot is fake compensation, pretending to be best at the very thing one is secretly least sure of. Someone with Saturn in Gemini talks nonstop at a party, afraid that in a moment of silence others will find out there is nothing interesting to say. The smokescreen works on strangers, and people who know them see through it at once. On projection, she says that when we hold down what is young and growing in ourselves, we go looking for a tyrant outside, whether a government, a system or a boss, because a tyrant outside is far easier to find than the inner tyrant who makes the rules. On contempt, she warns that whenever we feel scorn for someone, we should first grow a little suspicious of ourselves.
Saturn's Creative Compensation and Its Limits
After all this, Greene gives Saturn its real way forward, a creative compensation. You start from the beginning and honestly practice the very thing that embarrasses you. It may take years of carrying on through the embarrassment and the sense of falling short, and in the end you have a skill no one can take away. A person with Saturn in Gemini has to learn to speak directly and to write clearly, and someone who struggled at school when young may need to go back later on. What she says you have to tell yourself is: I am afraid of looking a fool, I may never be good at this, but I am going to do it anyway.
At the same time she keeps to a limit. She doesn't favor forcing a breakthrough with violent shocks, and says no one pours boiling water on roses and demands that they bloom in January. On humiliation, she says it is pride that creates it, and being willing to play the fool and laugh at yourself is the difference between humiliation and humility. Wherever there is something nobody is allowed to joke about, there is usually Saturn.
Chiron
Chiron's wound differs from Saturn's. Saturn is a lack, and what is lacking can be earned back through effort. Chiron is an undeserved wound, like something that was damaged before it left the factory, and it forces a person down a path they would never have chosen. With Saturn's wound you can still blame yourself or someone else. With Chiron there is no one to blame, so you blame the whole world, and its defence is a bitter outlook that sees everything in the darkest light. In the myth, the centaur Chiron took no part in the fighting, yet was wounded by mistake by an arrow of Heracles, and the wound never healed. Greene stresses that he did not become wise because he was wounded. It is simply that good people get hurt too, and there is nothing romantic about it.
She calls Chiron the planet concerned with right and wrong and with fairness, and it is precisely because a person carries an inner measure of fairness that the wound goes so deep.
Through Chiron we are trapped, because the very thing which makes us noble is also the very thing which dooms us to the wound.
So Chiron's house and sign show which kinds of things a person feels as most unfair. She describes some friends watching the evening news together. One stays angry for three weeks over a light sentence in a court case, another for three weeks over a politician taking bribes, and each has touched their own wound. The path only begins when you move from “why me?” to “being human is hard, and many people are hurt for no reason.” Chiron's most creative defence is to try to understand, and after that comes acceptance, which is not the same as giving up. She also says Chiron has few friends. Jupiter counts as half of one, and Saturn is a better one, because Saturn is realistic. Saturn does best through effort, and Chiron draws a line around how much that effort can be expected to achieve.
Saturn in Scorpio and the Closing Fairy Tale
On Saturn in Scorpio, Greene says Scorpio wants deep bonds without pretense or evasion, and it is precisely because closeness matters so much that it is guarded so fiercely. How tightly someone guards shows how deeply they need it. The book ends with a fairy tale. Golden apples are stolen from the king's orchard night after night, and the two capable princes both fall asleep on watch. The youngest, taken for a fool, makes himself a pillow of thorns that pricks him awake each time he starts to doze, and so he catches the thief. Greene says that sometimes it is the very pain that Saturn and Chiron bring that truly wakes us up.
How to Read This Book
If you want to start with one part, try the few dozen pages on Saturn in Part Two. Being denied, pretending, avoiding and envy are all things you can recognize in everyday life. If you don't know astrology well, it's better to read the introduction and the passages on the four elements first. Everything that follows stands on the one idea that a defence protects what matters most, and if you skip it you won't see why she keeps speaking up for defences.
The book has its hard parts too. It is a seminar transcript, with people cutting in all the time, so a topic is often pulled aside by a question and comes back a while later. It is also full of British people and events from the 1990s, actors, politicians, television programs and the royal family, which can be heavy going for readers who don't know them. Freud's terminology will make some people wince, and Greene herself says it can be swapped for words like “control.” In a few places she links physical discomfort with chart placements, while making clear that the placements are not the cause. Read these as one analyst's observations, and you needn't apply them to yourself. Chiron was discovered only in 1977, less than twenty years before the seminars. She doesn't regard Chiron as the ruler of any sign, and the book doesn't go through Chiron sign by sign, so here she gives a direction rather than a table you can look things up in.
In the seminars Greene goes through one chart after another, asking what this person is protecting. Your Psychological Defences in Depth puts the same question to your own birth chart. It starts with the signs of your Sun, Moon and Ascendant, finds which of fusion, control, competition and dissociation come to you most naturally, and says what each of these signs protects and what it looks like when it goes too far. Of the planets the book singles out as defences, it reads only those that have a say in your chart, then looks at the most heavily guarded places in the chart and at how projection carries what is inside out into the world. Saturn and Chiron carry the most weight. The report reads their signs, houses and aspects, the ways Saturn usually guards itself, which kinds of things Chiron makes you feel as most unfair, and where each planet's way forward lies. The years in which your Saturn return and the other turning points of this kind fall are worked out exactly for your chart. Finally it reads these lines of defence together and talks about how to live with them. It reads only the defensive side of the chart, and does not replace a full reading of the whole chart.
Your Psychological Defences in DepthSee report · $19From the chart to a written reading
The reports below are written readings, sent as a PDF by email.